Mosque Developers Ask West Bloomfield Township to Table Plans

At a Zoning Board of Appeals site visit Tuesday, officials tabled two requests from the Islamic Cultural Center.

Developers of a mosque at the corner of 14 Mile and Middlebelt Roads in West Bloomfield Township have requested that plans slated for review at the Planning Commission's Oct. 23 meeting be tabled. 

That request, which Islamic Cultural Association (ICA) representatives said was made to address concerns, led the Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) to table requests for a determination on height limitations for some of the building's architectural features and for an exemption from a requirement to build a masonry wall on the west property line.

During a Tuesday site visit, residents during public comment raised a number of issues, from whether it is appropriate to have a 3-4 story building on the property, to concerns about traffic. 

Long-time resident Mel Sternfeld, who lives near the school, arranged to have a boom truck present that would raise its boom to a height of 50 feet to show the scale of the project.

"We are on private property," ZBA chair David Robertson said, noting the "liability involved in something of that magnitude". He added the applicant was not willing to allow it. Instead, Sternfeld set up the boom in an adjacent neighborhood, so that it was visible from the property.

ICA representatives provided some perspective by pointing out the height of trees and other landmarks on or adjacent to the property. 

Board members raised a number of questions about the height of spires, domes and a minaret. Several said they would oppose granting an exemption for the masonry fence requirement. ICA attorney Richard Rattner, in response to questions raised at the Oct. 4 meeting, said a 6-foot fence on the west side of the property belongs to neighbors. The ICA would be willing to repair and maintain that fence, with the homeowners' permission, he said, and the area in front of then fence would be landscaped. 

Board secretary Cherie Van Vliet noted there was no requirement for residents to maintain the fence. She was concerned that ICA representatives had not talked with residents about the wall.

"In light of that, I don't think the township should waive its wall requirement," she said. If the ICA builds the wall, she said, the landscaping proposed should remain in place. 

During the meeting, Robertson reminded residents several times that the ZBA's scope was limited, and he encouraged residents and ICA representatives to set up a meeting to discuss neighborhood questions, which he said were "very appropriate", in his personal opinion.

"They are definitely questions I would be asking," he said. 

The board previously approved new construction of paved parking areas, and for the largest of two domes to be built at a height exceeding the maximum allowed in the township.

americans2 October 17, 2012 at 07:14 PM
Gayle Chappell October 17, 2012 at 08:14 PM
I'm really torn about whether to believe 'americans2' comment "Infidels!" was actually left by a Muslim and am far more inclined to believe it was posted by one of the various groups working so hard to stop the proposed mosque from ever being built. I have to admit that I am dismayed, repeatedly, at the Christians and Jews who are fighting this matter with such fervor and vitriol. I can only imagine how vocal they would be in their tremendous outrage if anyone put up the same kind of intolerant campaign against their erecting either a protestant or catholic church or a synagogue. I'd imagine they would be the first to start shouting about the right to freedom of religion promised by the Bill of Rights; however, the Muslim people trying to build their place of worship are doing so quietly, without the histrionics, shouted protesting or lawsuits by their 'fellow Americans'. I am ashamed of the behaviors I've witnessed during this long, drawn-out event.
Akad akad October 23, 2012 at 03:03 PM
No it was left by a Muslim. It is how they regard you who is not Muslim. Don't be naive. Sep 11 wasn't commuted by a few crackpots. They were just another offshoot of this religion of hate. Allowing mosques in our neighborhoods is like building AL Qaeda cells. What do you think they preach in these mosques? They preach spread the Islam by force and kill all disbelievers.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »